Banning books from schools is a controversial topic.
The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky is a book that has
been put on the list of books that should be banned. The book is about a boy
named Charlie and his journey through high school trying to find himself and
dealing with some hidden issues within. One of these issues is being molested.
Charlie being molested isn’t the only reference of sexual content in the book. This
is why perhaps parents and adults have tried to ban this book from schools.
However, I think teenagers, meaning ages 13 and up, should be able to read this
book because I think we should be mature enough.
Charlie
being molested is an example of a sexual reference in the book. Sam and Charlie
were about to have sex, when something Sam did made Charlie freak out. He soon
says “’I can’t do that anymore. I’m sorry,’ I said…But I wasn’t talking to Sam
anymore. I was taking to someone else.” Then on page 204, Charlie is dreaming
about watching TV with his Aunt Helen. “My brother and my sister and I were watching
television with my Aunt Helen… And she was doing what Sam was doing. (End of
Dream)… But I kind of figured out that everything I dreamt about my Aunt Helen
was true.” Parents and adults might not want children reading this because of
the reference of being molested. However, I believe that this scene itself is
not graphic. It does not go into descriptive details about what was happening.
Therefore, I think teenagers should be able to read this book.
Another
example of a sexual reference is Sam being molested. Sam was asking Charlie if
he had ever been kissed and ends up telling him about her first kiss on page
70. “She told me about the first time she was kissed. She told me that it was
one of her dad’s friends. She was seven.” Being that the man was her dad’s age,
Sam was molested. Parents and adults might not want their children reading this
because it does mention and reference possible underage relationships. However,
teenagers should be able to read this because it is already implemented into
most of our minds that child-adult relationships are wrong and illegal.
The
last example of a sexual reference in the book is a graphic rape scene. Charlie’s
brother and sister were throwing a party when a boy named Dave and his girlfriend
came into Charlie’s room. One thing led to another and this was what happened, “…but
it kept going on, and they kept doing other things and she kept saying ’no.’
Even when I covered my ears I could still hear that.” Dave had just raped his
girlfriend. There is a more descriptive part that goes into more detail on the
page before. This scene is an example of why adults might not want children reading
this. On the other hand, teenagers should be allowed to read this because we should
be mature enough. Adults expect a certain type of behavior from us. They expect
us to be mature enough to not laugh at certain texts if it’s not for comedic
purposes. I think the same type of maturity should be extended in this case as
well.
From
reading this text, I have learned that there is content that is not meant for
the immature to read. There are adult texts out in bookstores and libraries. On
the contrary, teenagers should be allowed to read such texts as well because we
are mature enough to read these types of texts. Teachers and parents encourage reading
into our lives, and yes, there are texts meant for adults in bookstores and
such, but the choice should remain with the student of what he or she wants to
read.
No comments:
Post a Comment